Skip to content
Singulariki

Budget Analysts vs Payroll and Timekeeping Clerks

Side-by-side · O*NET · BLS · AI-exposure research · Anthropic Economic Index

A factual, source-backed comparison of Budget Analysts and Payroll and Timekeeping Clerks on the dimensions both occupations carry. Every figure is a position within an independent published dataset — not a verdict on which job is better, safer, or more “future-proof.”

Budget Analysts Payroll and Timekeeping Clerks
Median pay · BLS OEWS
$87,930
$55,290
Employment · BLS OEWS
47,170
156,950
AI exposure (percentile) · task overlap, not automation
76th pct
73rd pct

At a glance

Dimension Budget Analysts Payroll and Timekeeping Clerks
Median pay $87,930 $55,290
Employment 47,170 156,950
Employment outlook (2024–34) · BLS projection About average (+1.0%) Declining (-16.7%)
Annual openings · BLS projection 3,100 13,000
Typical education · O*NET Most of these occupations require a four-year bachelor's degree, but some do not. Most occupations in this zone require training in vocational schools, related on-the-job experience, or an associate's degree.
AI exposure · published exposure studies High · 76th pct High · 73rd pct
Global GenAI gradient · ILO ISCO-08 · via crosswalk 89th pct · 51% of tasks 98th pct · 61% of tasks
Observed AI use · Anthropic Economic Index Augmentation-leaning (76.6%) Augmentation-leaning (52.9%)
Mostly remote-capable · Dingel–Neiman Yes Yes

Pay and employment are BLS OEWS estimates; outlook and openings are BLS 2024–2034 projections; AI exposure and observed-use figures come from separate research and reflect exposure and usage, not predictions that either job will disappear. Compare like with like.

Skills

Shared: Economics and Accounting, Mathematics, English Language, Mathematics, Critical Thinking, Oral Comprehension, Written Comprehension, Oral Expression, Mathematical Reasoning, Number Facility, Reading Comprehension, Active Listening, Speaking, Complex Problem Solving, Judgment and Decision Making, Problem Sensitivity, Deductive Reasoning, Information Ordering, Administration and Management, Written Expression, Inductive Reasoning, Speech Clarity, Administrative, Near Vision, Computers and Electronics, Active Learning, Customer and Personal Service, Speech Recognition, Writing, Monitoring, Category Flexibility, Social Perceptiveness, Time Management, Perceptual Speed, Selective Attention.

Specific to Budget Analysts

  • Management of Financial Resources
  • Systems Analysis
  • Systems Evaluation
  • Fluency of Ideas
  • Law and Government

Specific to Payroll and Timekeeping Clerks

  • Personnel and Human Resources
  • Service Orientation
  • Coordination
  • Flexibility of Closure
  • Communications and Media

Knowledge, skills & abilities O*NET rates as important for each occupation. “Shared” are common to both; the columns list what is distinctive to each (top by the order O*NET surfaces).

Tools & technology

Shared: Data base user interface and query software , Spreadsheet software , Office suite software , Electronic mail software , Business intelligence and data analysis software , Presentation software , Word processing software , Enterprise resource planning ERP software , Accounting software , Human resources software .

Specific to Budget Analysts

Specific to Payroll and Timekeeping Clerks

Full profiles

This page is a summary. See the complete source-backed profile for Budget Analysts or Payroll and Timekeeping Clerks — tasks, the full skill graph, tools, work context, preparation, wages by percentile, industries, AI exposure and the AI work map.

More comparisons

Related occupations you can place side by side on the same sourced scale.

Sources for this page

Every figure above traces to a named public dataset and the exact release below — not hand-written opinion. See the full methodology for what each measure does and does not mean.

Data compiled June 2, 2026. Figures are estimates, not advice.

Cite this page
Plain

Singulariki. "Budget Analysts vs Payroll and Timekeeping Clerks." Singulariki: a source-backed encyclopedia of work. Built from O*NET 30.3; BLS Occupational Employment and Wage Statistics (OEWS) May 2024; BLS Employment Projections 2024–2034; Anthropic Economic Index v4 (2026-01-15) + v2 (2025-03-27); Microsoft “Working with AI” working-with-ai; “GPTs are GPTs” (Eloundou et al.) arXiv 2303.10130; AI Occupational Exposure (AIOE) Felten, Raj & Seamans; ILO / Gmyrek et al. GenAI exposure gradient 2025; IBS O*NET-SOC ↔ ISCO-08 occupation crosswalk 2022; Frey & Osborne (2013) frey-osborne-automation; Dingel & Neiman (2020) dingel-neiman-workathome. Accessed June 7, 2026. https://singulariki.com/compare/budget-analysts-vs-payroll-and-timekeeping-clerks

APA

Singulariki. (2026). Budget Analysts vs Payroll and Timekeeping Clerks. Singulariki: a source-backed encyclopedia of work. Retrieved June 7, 2026, from https://singulariki.com/compare/budget-analysts-vs-payroll-and-timekeeping-clerks

BibTeX 
@misc{singulariki-budget-analysts-vs-payroll-and-timekeeping-clerks,
  title  = {Budget Analysts vs Payroll and Timekeeping Clerks},
  author = {{Singulariki}},
  year   = {2026},
  note   = {O*NET 30.3; BLS Occupational Employment and Wage Statistics (OEWS) May 2024; BLS Employment Projections 2024–2034; Anthropic Economic Index v4 (2026-01-15) + v2 (2025-03-27); Microsoft “Working with AI” working-with-ai; “GPTs are GPTs” (Eloundou et al.) arXiv 2303.10130; AI Occupational Exposure (AIOE) Felten, Raj & Seamans; ILO / Gmyrek et al. GenAI exposure gradient 2025; IBS O*NET-SOC ↔ ISCO-08 occupation crosswalk 2022; Frey & Osborne (2013) frey-osborne-automation; Dingel & Neiman (2020) dingel-neiman-workathome. Accessed June 7, 2026},
  url    = {https://singulariki.com/compare/budget-analysts-vs-payroll-and-timekeeping-clerks}
}

Citations name the underlying public dataset releases — they reflect what this page is built from, not just the URL.